Skip to content

Providing Care in Sonoma, Napa, & Marin Counties
Call (707) 573-1003

Do Men and Women Respond to Tests for MCI Differently?

Mild cognitive impairment, or MCI, is a condition in which an older adult suffers from memory impairment and a decline in their cognitive abilities. Up to 20 percent of people aged 65 and older have MCI. Doctors diagnose the problem by administering verbal tests to the older adult. However, a new study suggests that men and women respond differently to the tests, so scoring them by gender could change who is diagnosed with MCI and who is not.

Senior Care Oakmont CA - Do Men and Women Respond to Tests for MCI Differently?

Senior Care Oakmont CA – Do Men and Women Respond to Tests for MCI Differently?

MCI Tests and Gender

Research shows that the average woman has better verbal skills than the average man. However, the tests used to diagnose MCI don’t reflect those differences. To find out how gender differences might affect MCI diagnosis, researchers used data from 985 people who had participated in the Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging Initiative. Using the data, the researchers recalculated the cut-off scores for men and women separately instead of using the same score for both.

Using the new scores, the researchers determined that 10 percent more women would be diagnosed with MCI. The new scores for men, on the other hand, would result in 10 percent fewer cases of MCI. This means that under the current guidelines, women who should be diagnosed with MCI are being missed while some men are being diagnosed who shouldn’t be.

The research is new, and no medical guidelines have been changed based on it. That means that if your aging relative has received a diagnosis of MCI, you should continue to follow the doctor’s advice.

MCI Symptoms

A diagnosis of MCI often begins with family caregivers noticing symptoms in their older family members. Some of the symptoms to watch for are:

  • Increased forgetfulness.
  • Forgetting important appointments.
  • Having difficulty following the thread of a conversation, book, or movie.
  • Trouble completing tasks with multiple steps, understanding instructions, or making decisions.
  • Getting lost in familiar places.
  • Acting more impulsively or making poor choices.

People who have MCI may also experience emotional disorders, such as:

  • Anxiety.
  • Depression.
  • Apathy.
  • Irritability.
  • Aggression.

Tips for People with MCI

MCI can progress to dementia, but there are ways your older family member can lessen the chances of that happening. Some tips for living with MCI are:

  • Take all prescription medications as directed, since they help to keep underlying conditions that can lead to dementia under control.
  • Quit smoking.
  • Reduce stress.
  • Stick to a regular routine to minimize memory issues.
  • Use calendars, notes, and reminders to prevent forgetting important dates.

In addition to following the tips above, senior care can also help older adults with MCI to cope with the condition better. Senior care providers can offer medication reminders, so the older adult doesn’t forget to take prescription medications. They can also help the senior to follow their daily routine and remember to go to appointments. In fact, a senior care provider can drive your aging relative to their appointments, ensuring they do not get lost on the way.


If you or an aging loved one are considering hiring Senior Care Services in Oakmont CA, call At Your Service Home Care.  Call today! (707) 573-1003

Lucy Andrews DNP, RN, MS

In 1988, after working as a clinical nurse in the University Health System at UC San Francisco, Lucy Andrews started understanding home care.

She became a discharge planner and immediately fell in love with the concept of home care and the autonomous clinical practice it affords nurses. Dr. Lucy was hooked and has been a strong supporter of home care ever since.Believing people need advocates in healthcare systems, she has championed that cause across the acute care and post-acute care setting.

Dr. Lucy has worked in every aspect of home care from Medicare Certified, DME, Infusion, Hospice and finally Private Duty/Private Pay services. She also works as a home care consultant across the country and as a legal nurse consultant for the home care industry.

Having worked in all areas of home care, Dr. Lucy has a well-rounded perspective of the challenges facing patients, families and the home care industry, and as a provider she advocates for patients through the maze of health care services. Dr. Lucy celebrated over 37 years as a nurse and patient advocate.

Dr. Lucy has a Baccalaureate Degree in Nursing from Lewis University, Romeoville, Illinois.In 1994, she received her Masters of Science in Health Service Administration from St. Mary's University, Moraga, California. Dr. Lucy received her Doctor of Nursing Practice awarded in 2016, graduating with Distinction and a 4.0 GPA.

She did her doctoral work on the global dementia crisis, aging and prevention strategies for healthy living. Developed dementia and Alzheimer's disease plans for aging patients leaving the hospital setting or entering long-term care or home health and hospice environments. She also developed a specialized program for those at risk for dementia and Alzheimer’s disease.

In 1992, Dr. Lucy was designated CAHSAH Certified Home Care Administrator in the inaugural offering of this designation through the California Association for Health Services at Home (CAHSAH).

She is the founder and CEO of Creative Solutions Home Care Consulting Services and At Your Service Nursing & Home Care, a concierge nursing & home care agency that provides the services she believes are essential for seniors to age in place.She offers a higher level of care allowing people to be in their own homes with an emphasis on independence, safety, and quality of life.

Dr. Lucy is the Vice Chair of the Board of Directors for the National Association for Home Care and Hospice (NAHC) and sits on the Board of Directors for California Association for Health Services at Home (CAHSAH).

She has served on the boards for both state and national board associations, and is currently on the following boards and committees: Board of Directors, California State Association for Health Services at Home (CAHSAH), 2002-present, National Association for Home Care and Hospice (NAHC's) Private Duty Home Care Association Director, and multiple state and national home care committees.

Dr. Lucy goes to Washington, DC, several times a year to advocate for senior services and home care issues. She was past Commissioner for the Sonoma Commission on Human Rights.She is past chair of the local Senior Advocacy Services.

Latest posts by Lucy Andrews DNP, RN, MS (see all)